Finance Commission Grants to Cities Remain Critically Limited
Why in the News ?
Debate has emerged over the 16th Finance Commission’s recommendations on urban local body (ULB) funding, as transfers to cities remain extremely low despite urban centres generating a large share of India’s GDP and government revenues, raising concerns about fiscal autonomy and federalism.
Limited Fiscal Transfers to Urban Local Bodies:
- Urban centres contribute nearly 67% of India’s GDP and around 90% of government revenues, yet financial transfers to Urban Local Bodies (ULBs) remain limited, creating structural barriers to inclusive development.
- Under the 15th Finance Commission, urban local bodies received around ₹1.2–1.3 lakh crore over five years, which amounted to roughly 0.12–0.13% of GDP.
- The 16th Finance Commission proposes ₹3.56 lakh crore for ULBs between 2026–2031, translating to about ₹75,000 crore annually.
- However, with India’s projected GDP of ₹400 lakh crore, the proportion of transfers to cities remains nearly unchanged at around 0.13% of GDP.
- With India’s urban population expected to exceed 600 million by 2030, per-capita urban transfers may stagnate or decline in real terms, affecting equal access to basic services and gender equality in urban development.
Performance Conditions and Federal Concerns
- The 16th Finance Commission has linked part of urban grants to performance-based conditions, limiting fiscal flexibility for cities.
- Conditions include improving fiscal discipline, conducting regular local body elections, publishing audited accounts, and establishing State Finance Commissions to ensure equal rights in governance.
- About 20% of funds are conditional, meaning cities may lose funding if these benchmarks are not met.
- The Commission also encourages cities to increase Own Source Revenue (OSR) through property taxes and user charges, with a target of ₹1,200 per household.
- Critics argue that such conditions may undermine State autonomy, as urban development is constitutionally a State subject, and these requirements could perpetuate structural barriers to effective local governance and women’s rights in municipal decision-making.
| About Finance Commission and Urban Local Bodies : ● Finance Commission: A constitutional body under Article 280 that recommends the distribution of tax revenues between the Centre and States and grants to local governments. ● Urban Local Bodies (ULBs): Municipal institutions such as Municipal Corporations, Municipal Councils, and Nagar Panchayats, responsible for urban governance and service delivery. ● Own Source Revenue (OSR): Revenue generated by local governments through property taxes, user charges, fees, and local levies. ● Tied Grants: Funds provided for specific purposes such as water supply, sanitation, and wastewater management, limiting flexibility in spending. ● Fiscal Federalism: Refers to the division of financial powers and resources between different levels of government, ensuring balanced governance. |